Filed under: Shakespeare
-
BRINEGAR Charlton, DEBRA Lynn. Gender and Power, women in the plays of Shakespeare and Lope de Vega. Ann Arbor: UMI, 1988
BRINEGAR Charlton, DEBRA Lynn. Gender and Power, women in the plays of Shakespeare and Lope de Vega. Ann Arbor: UMI, 1988
To conclude with this paper, we can realise that Shakespeare in his plays used to critised the submissive position from women at this era. As he was against this tyranny that a father, husband or uncle could possess, and with that take opinions or facts that did not belong to them. In Much Ado About Nothing Beatrice breaks the conventions through her acts and freedom, being represented as equal as men, reaching a high social value and great importance compared to man’s superiority ideology.
It is noticeable here that in such era in which William Shakespeare was living it was strange, and at the same time, rebellious, that an author with such characteristics was able to write in so open mind conscious, about women rights, supporting the idea that they do not have to be submissive, but fight and be in equal position with men.
Concerning to the principle point to develop in this essay, women role in Shakespeare’s comedies, the author has been considered as feminist by many modern critics. For example Saphiro goes so far as to claim that Shakespeare was “the noblest feminist of them all”. Maybe he was not for sure a feminist, but he had a deep sensitivity toward women. When we look critically to a Shakespearean work, we can see that many of his plays include strong female characters that strive to demolish typical gender role stereotypes. Shakespeare suggests that women may not be the weaker vessel as was commonly believed.
Female characters in specially Shakespeare’s comedies could be classified as heroines, equal to men in intelligence and wit. That is the main reason because we are analyzing this role compared to with the character Beatrice in his work Much Ado About Nothing (1598). This play starts with the coming back from war of many men, and women waiting for them. It is already here when we see the function women had at this moment, men were those who had to fight, and women had just to wait at home, taking care of children and houseworks. It is called the usual patriarchal society of Shakespeare’s times. It is in Messina (Italy) where the plot happens and where Leonato welcomed home the man soldiers, such as Don Pedro of Aragon and Claudio. They, also with Benedick arrive to Leonato’s house and his niece Beatrice was also there. The lady and Benedick had a war of wits, insulting each other, and sometimes it seemed as they were completely in love. The play mainly revolves around two pairs of lovers, in one part Beatrice and Benedick and in the other part, Claudio and Hero, Leonato’s daughter. The plot is envolved around obstacle to the union of the two last mentioned lovers, and the love-hate relationship of Beatrice and Benedick. Benedich thinks he hates Beatrice but in fact it is love and vice versa.
In most Shakespeare’s comedies women are treated as manipulated under the power of men, usually these characters are fathers, husbands, uncles… Even this main objective is reflected in his works, Shakespeare also describes the notion of female empowerment, being strong, independent… but without forgetting the also repressed women who are submissive. According to Shakespeare’s works we can differ many kinds of women represented in plays, depending on the situation the girl is from the leader as can be the father, uncle or husband. In the case of Much Ado About Nothing, we have a clear example of “niece and daughter archetype”. In this case female characters are described as submissive and easily controlled.
To start with the example of Hero, it can be the best to explain the example of a “daughter archetype”. Hero is the daughter of Leonato, her father and the leader, Hero lives under total control, especially with regard to courtship. Along the story we see many examples that clarify this control, as for example in this quotation: “Daughter, remember what I told you. If the Prince do solicit you in that kind, you know your answer”. Don Pedro wanted to ask Hero’s hand in marriage, and in this case the father had to choose the answer, considered correct according to him. So he is not only influent in her actions, also in her words. Hero does not show sign of acting under her own volition anywhere in the play.
Then we have another example in the play who represents the power of women, it is Beatrice, the niece of Leonato. She is brave and with a strong character. She shows it for example when she interrupts the conversation between Leonato an a Messenger. It is like she is able to do it, she feels strong and she does not find any inconvenient of doing this “rude” act at Elizabethan times. It is the act which shows it:
(Act 1, scene 1)
BEATRICE: I pray you, is Signior Mountanto returned from the wars or no?
Messenger: I know none of that name, lady: there was none such in the army of any sort.
LEONATO: What is he that you ask for, niece?
HERO My cousin means Signior Benedick of Padua.
Messenger: Oh, he’s returned; and as pleasant as ever he was.
BEATRICE: He set up his bills here in Messina and challenged Cupid at the flight; and my uncle’s fool, reading the challenge, subscribed for Cupid, and challenged him at the bird-bolt. I pray you, how many hath he killed and eaten in these wars? But how many hath he killed? for indeed I promised to eat all of his killing.
(Act 1, Scene 1 Before LEONATO’S house – of the complete works .
Beatrice is the clear example of heroine who is known for her firm opposition to marriage and for her verbal dueling with Benedick. With these acts Beatrice breaks the conventions through her speech freedom.
With both characters we have explained before we have a clear opposition between them and their roles. Beatrice is a strong and rebellious woman who protest against the conventional attitude of women at Elizabethan times. She presents herself as equal to man, as she can argue, fight, judge, speak… Being much different than Beatrice we find the daughter of Leonato, Hero who represents women’s submission. She is a docile and sweet girl who always follow the opinion of her father, doing always what he wants, as the fact of being marriage to Claudio, whose agreement was from the father’s part. She does not speak almost nothing, and she does it, it is never about herself or reveling against something, it is because she wants to see together Beatrice and Benedict together, taking an active role. But generally she always agrees and obeys without opposition all the decisions taken by men.
William Shakespeare was born in 1564, and died 54 years later. His studies were based on Latin rethoric, logic and literature. In just 23 years he is attributed of writing 38 plays. He is the most widely fead of all authors and his life and works popularity, in English speaking countries, is the second, after only to the Bible. That is why the interest and importance about this author. His work as playwright what brought fame to Shakespeare in this era. His production, in a total fourteen comedies, ten tragedies and ten historical dramas, is an exquisite compendium of feelings, pain and ambitions of the human being.
Referring to his comedies we can distinguish its fantasy and the poetic sense in this period, as for example in Midsummer’s Night Dream; the prodigious domain of the author in versification permitted him to differ characters depending on the way they talked. Such characteristic as the language made of his plays the most famous and read thanks to the naturalness of its usage.
From 1600, Shakespeare published his great tragedies and the calles “obscure comedies”. Later, in 1608 changed the register and started in the tragic-comedy genre, often with a happy ending.
Shakespeare only published sixteen of his plays while he was alive. That is why some of his plays could be lost and consequently, not published.
Concerning to the principle point to develop in this essay, women role in Shakespeare’s comedies, the author has been considered as feminist by many modern critics. For example Saphiro goes so far as to claim that Shakespeare was “the noblest feminist of them all”. Maybe he was not for sure a feminist, but he had a deep sensitivity toward women. When we look critically to a Shakespearean work, we can see that many of his plays include strong female characters that strive to demolish typical gender role stereotypes. Shakespeare suggests that women may not be the weaker vessel as was commonly believed.
Summing up this essay, we have clearly realised how much he expresses his socialism idea through the text, talking always against totalitarianism of the epoque. We can find an article he wrote called “Why I write” (1947), where we can read his thoughts. “Every line of serious work that I have written since 1936 has been written, directly or indirectly, against totalitarianism and for socialism… Animal Farm was the First Book in which I tried, with fall consciousness of what I was doing, to fuse political purpose and a artistic purpose into one whole”.All the experiences related with his young life, at Spanish Civil War , where the main influences in his long work, and we can see that reflected in “Animal Farm”, but also his splendid artistic style, as the novel tried to focus in politics but also its influences in the English Language. At these times English was in a very bad state, and as a consequence it lead to a decayed civilisation. So it is obvious that this fault has a cause in politics. But Orwell is one of the writers who spoke more about politics joining it to a excellent artistic style.
Animal Farm was one of the best satyrical and historic books that Orwell published along his life. He treated the Russian problematic; as he criticized the Russian system, this book has not a proper acceptance in Great Britain, because it was a clear ally of the Russian government. Orwell analyse each member of Russian society representing them by animals, and their politics function. There is a clear revolution against Communism, as Orwell was so conscious about it. Some of the patterns he points he follow when he write the book were: democracy as ideal political system, critics to doctrinarian socialists, Communism critics, Man in front of power, abuse of power, defense of freedom, freedom of thoughts, speech freedom, use of propaganda, search for the truth, history destruction, concern about social injustice… These are some of the main points Orwell referred to in the book, always in an allegorical way, representing these facts through animals and their environment. That is why we have to read the text as we were reading a political treaty, not a simple novel.
LÁZARO LAFUENTE, Luis Alberto. Pensamiento y obra de George Orwell: estudio de Animal Farm como síntesis de toda su producción literaria. Universidad de Valladolid, 1987.
Accordingly with the given definition we are going to point out the most important and significant things that appear in the plot and are relevant to understand it. Even we have to say and remember that the whole story is a symbol, as if we know something about politics, when we read it we immediately realize that it is a clear totalitarian society (=farm where animals are living) with its leader (=pigs) and its followers (=the rest of the animals), and everything together represents the struggle happened in the Russian Revolution.
As first example of symbol we are explaining the major characters with their representations in real life at Russian Revolution times. Marx is represented by Old Major, who taught Animalism with egalitarian ideals. Following the pattern that workers keep doing the work, while rich keep the money, the animals revolt starts. After the revolution Old Major died. We compare it also to Marx because of the speech he gives to the animals which is similar to Communist Manifesto. Then the second representation we can highlight is the one from Napoleon and Snowball who are in reality Stalin and Trotsky respectively. Snowball was young, smart, a good speaker; and Trostky was also a leader of “October Revolution”, he was a pure communist who followed Marx and who wanted to improve life for all in Russia. Then, Napoleon was not as clever as Snowball, he was cruel, selfish and very corrupts and he made use of the most loyal animals to control the other; and Stalin as Napoleon was not an educated man, he cared for power, and killed all those who opposed him. All of them have a superior knowledge and they assume the leadership. We can also talk about the other pig, called Squealer, who used to talk a lot to convince animals to follow Napoleon ideas trying always to change and manipulate the Commandments. He can be characterizes with all the propaganda department of Lenin’s government who worked for Stalin to support his image through telling lies and convincing people to follow Stalin.
But there are not only the “major” representatives in the Revolution, we can also find population characterized along the plot. We can find two horses, Clover and Boxer, which are representative of common workers. We can see now that the same function animals have at the farm, the real characters had at the Russian Revolution. We have further information about others but less relevant characters here:

Another symbol to analyze is the farm itself, as the place where everything happen and all animals live, «It was about this time that the pigs suddenly moved into the farmhouse and took up residence there.» (Orwell, 45). It is also showing how high authority exist inside the place, and how slowly pigs take the control over the farm. It represents the place where avarice and wish predominated in characters. It is also here where Napoleon and the pigs take over, and in Russian Revolution terms it would symbolize the country “Russia” and the Soviet Union under Cummunist Party rule. We can point out the Kremlin, still nowadays an important place to Russian leaders. Farm’s internal structure is like a nation, with a government (the pigs), a police form or army (the dogs), a working class (the other animals), and state holidays and rituals.
Then, we are explaining the Seven Commandments symbolism. Specifically it is referring to the Communist Manifesto. They have an extremely symbolism as they illustrate the manipulation in the story and the differences between pigs and working animals, leaders and followers.

Those Commandaments consist in the combination of ideas pigs had at the beginning of the novel to form a list of rules or laws that all farm animals would live by. «The seven commandments would be inscribed on the wall; they would form an unalterable law by which the animals must live by forever,» said Snowball. (Orwell, 15) These laws are the basic principles of Animalism, and it was not possible to change them. When they were set, the main idea was how helpful they are that they can change to a better life-style at the farm, but power and ambition broke it. We say that it did not work because it is the clear example of the beginning of the struggle between pigs, and they altered these rules to suit themselves.
The barn was another symbolism example to highlight in the story. On its wall is where pigs wrote the seven commandments.

It represents the collective memory of a nation and its information changes along the story just like our memory .
It is also here where ruling-class pigs alter the principles of Animalism and in which the working-class animals are mystified, but accepting these changes it represents the way a powerful institution can revise a community’s concept of history to strengthen its control. Like that oppressors (those who had the power), gain control of the nation’s identity after being revised its origins and development; consequently the oppressed (normal workers), come to depend upon the authorities.
Finally, and as other of the most relevant symbols in the story, we find the Windmill. It shows significance through the animals section on building it without human assistance, just with determination and hard work, animals completed it by working together as one in order to show their great achieve
ment as society, but always through manipulation and lies from the oppressors. It is some way to symbolise that they are able to get triumph, but always making as politicians, promising what they could not carry on which will finish with the disappointment of the general public. Overall, the windmill represents the pigs’ manipulation upon the other animals just for their own gain, being very selfish. Pigs manipulate the common animals by working in building this, which will lastly earn the pigs more money. From the allegorical point of view that we are also analysing, the windmill represents the enormous modernizations projects undertaken in Soviet Russia after the Russian Revolution.

It meant that the country was modernized and industrialized but there was no improvement in the standard
of living of the ordinary people. Consequently with what we have said, the destruction of the Windmill, what happened twice, represented failure.
Mr Jones is the owner of a farm who died after having repeated that everyone, every animal, should be equal. After this happens, it is the turn for the pigs to take the leadership role saying that it is time for a revolution, animals should do rebel. There are two pigs who are the most important characters in the plot, Napoleon and Snowball. Their main aim is to tell all the rest of animals that they have to follow some patterns in order to be loyal to each one, they call this idea “Animalism”, followed by its seven Commandments or rules. They start to share their knowledge about Animalism to the more weak animals such as the horse or the sheep. This regime was very interesting at the beginning for the rest of animals, but little by little animals realized that everything is not being as pigs promised. As times goes by, pigs Napoleon and Snowball have troubles but do not stop having the rest of animals working for them. At the end, many animals die, as for example Boxer,the most loyal at the farm; after being sent to do a hard work. It is here when pigs realize that they cannot tell the pigs from the humans and vice versa.

First of all we have to know what “symbol” means. It can be an object, image, word… that represents something else by association, resemblance or convention. In the case of Animal Farm we have to make some distinction and speak singularly about Political Symbolism), it’s a rhetorical device central of the work’s meaning. It differs from the “simple” symbol from being always related to a political standpoint. Much of the recent literature has studied this political symbolism, and as an example we can distinguish what Abner Cohen (social anthropologist) said, “most of the symbols that are politically significant are overtly nonpolitical. Often, the less obviously political in form symbols are, the more efficacious politically they prove to be…” . Here there is one more prove about the importance such political symbolism has, saying that one mere object that we think can be the least significant, then it results to be the most symbolic and the one which provides us more information about the text. That is what happens in the novella we are analyzing. Most of the political symbolism we can find in Animal Farm is in the characters themselves, characterized as animals who are living together in a farm. And all this life style that we will explain in the following lines, represents the Russian Revolution.
Animal Farm is a critic and allegorical novel written by George Orwell in 1945, whose film adaptation was in 1954. The author was born in India in 1903, but was educated in England. Having lived in many countries such as India and France he finished going back to England where he started to write his first articles for a magazine. It was just the beginning of becoming one of the most recognized writers; also in the literary journalism.

Known to all are his political tendencies, always being interested towards socialism. The period he was living in was the following World War One, and it was his most influential feature about politics. As he pointed out «Hence, at the age of seventeen or eighteen, I was both a snob and a revolutionary. I was against all authority … and I loosely described myself as a Socialist…” (“Pensamiento y obra de George Orwell”, Luis Alberto Lázaro de Lafuente). It is clear his dislike above totalitarianism and capitalism, after having suffered in some way the Russian Revolution and its clear and problematic leader Lenin. To show his dislike above the totalitarian political tendency, at the end of 1936 he fought in the Spanish Civil War for the communist republicans against fascism. At this time it was when he was diagnosed with tuberculosis, the illness that will kill him in 1950.
To show his political beliefs and disagreements he used to write some novels where he clearly reflected the way he thought in front of political facts, showing always his “left point of view”, his socialism tendency. Two clear examples of that are Animal Farm and 1984, both of them show his anti-totalitarian standpoint, having in common in their plots the existence of a Big Brother, a person who has all the power above population and whose rules have to be followed in order to survive. In this essay we will deeply study the first mentioned story, Animal Farm, which is a clear example of an oppressive government. It uses animals living in a farm to represent reality and its people during the Russian Revolution.